Top 15 Best Restaurants in Fort Myers, FL

When it comes to finding the best places to eat in Fort Myers, FL, you’re in for a treat. This vibrant city is home to a wide range of restaurants that cater to every culinary desire. From fresh seafood to mouthwatering steaks, there’s something to satisfy every palate. Whether you’re a local looking for new dining recommendations or a visitor planning your trip, I’ve got you covered with this list of the top 15 restaurants in Fort Myers.

Table of Contents

Key Takeaways:

Fort Myers, FL offers a diverse and vibrant food scene with top-notch restaurants.
From seafood to steak, there’s a restaurant to suit every taste in Fort Myers.
Whether you’re a local or a visitor, these restaurant recommendations will help you find the best dining experiences.
These 15 restaurants have been carefully selected for their unforgettable dining experiences and delicious menus.
Get ready to indulge in the culinary delights of Fort Myers, FL!

Next Door

Next Door is an Italian restaurant located in Cape Coral, just minutes away from Fort Myers. With its elegant ambiance and delicious menu, it has become a favorite among locals and tourists alike. The restaurant offers a wide range of Italian dishes, from homemade pasta to mouthwatering pizzas. It’s the perfect spot for a romantic dinner or a special occasion.

When you step into Next Door, you’ll be greeted by a warm and inviting atmosphere. The decor is modern yet cozy, creating the perfect setting for a memorable dining experience. Whether you’re celebrating a special milestone or simply enjoying a night out, Next Door provides the ideal ambiance.

The menu at Next Door is a celebration of authentic Italian flavors. Each dish is crafted with care and made using only the finest ingredients. From classic favorites like spaghetti carbonara to signature creations like grilled octopus with lemon aioli, there’s something to satisfy every palate.

“Next Door is like a slice of Italy in the heart of Cape Coral. The flavors are bold, the portions are generous, and the service is top-notch. It’s my go-to spot for a taste of Italy in Fort Myers.”

Next Door also offers an extensive wine list, featuring both local and imported wines. Whether you’re a wine connoisseur or just looking for the perfect pairing, their knowledgeable staff can help you find the ideal bottle to complement your meal.

Signature Dishes at Next Door

Homemade gnocchi with creamy gorgonzola sauce
Wood-fired margherita pizza with fresh basil
Tender veal piccata with lemon butter sauce
Decadent tiramisu with layers of mascarpone and espresso-soaked ladyfingers

Next Door is not just a restaurant; it’s an experience. From the moment you walk in, you’ll be treated to exceptional service, mouthwatering food, and a welcoming atmosphere. Whether you’re a local looking for a new dining spot or a visitor wanting to explore the culinary scene of Fort Myers, Next Door is a must-visit destination.

The Green Flash

If you’re looking for a picturesque dining experience, look no further than The Green Flash in Captiva Island. This waterfront restaurant offers stunning views of the ocean and an extensive menu of American cuisine. From fresh seafood to juicy steaks, every dish is expertly prepared and full of flavor. It’s the ideal place to enjoy a sunset dinner with loved ones.

At The Green Flash, you can savor the taste of the sea with their delectable seafood options. Indulge in their succulent shrimp scampi or try their signature crab-stuffed flounder for a truly unforgettable meal. If you prefer land-based fare, their tender steaks, such as the mouthwatering filet mignon, will delight your taste buds.

But it’s not just the food that makes The Green Flash a must-visit restaurant. The breathtaking waterfront location provides a serene and romantic setting for your dining experience. Imagine sipping a cocktail as you watch the sun dip below the horizon, painting the sky with vibrant hues. The Green Flash offers an idyllic atmosphere that perfectly complements the delicious cuisine.

Whether you’re celebrating a special occasion or simply looking to enjoy a memorable meal, The Green Flash is the place to be. Make a reservation today and treat yourself to an extraordinary dining experience in the heart of Captiva Island.

Mastello

If you’re a steak lover in Fort Myers, you simply cannot miss Mastello. This upscale steakhouse offers a sophisticated dining experience that combines exquisite flavors with elegant ambiance. From the moment you step in, you’ll be greeted with top-notch service and a menu that showcases the finest cuts of meat.

At Mastello, each steak is cooked to perfection, ensuring a melt-in-your-mouth experience with every bite. Whether you prefer a juicy ribeye or a tender filet mignon, the quality and flavor are unparalleled. Pair your steak with a selection from their curated wine list to enhance your dining experience.

The elegant decor of Mastello sets the stage for a memorable evening of fine dining. The sleek and modern interiors create a refined atmosphere, perfect for special occasions or intimate gatherings. Impeccable attention to detail and personalized service add an extra touch of luxury to your meal.

So, if you’re in search of the ultimate steakhouse experience in Fort Myers, look no further than Mastello. Indulge in the finest cuts of meat, savor the flavors, and revel in the sophistication of this remarkable establishment.

“Mastello is my go-to place for a memorable steak dinner. The quality of the meat and the overall dining experience are exceptional. It’s the perfect choice for a special occasion or when you simply want to treat yourself to fine dining.”
– Jessica D.

Gather – Cape Coral

I recently had the pleasure of dining at Gather, a contemporary American restaurant located in Cape Coral. This restaurant stands out for its innovative cuisine and stylish atmosphere. From the moment I walked through the door, I knew I was in for a treat.

The menu at Gather is a carefully curated selection of dishes that blend traditional flavors with modern techniques. Each dish is thoughtfully prepared and beautifully presented, showcasing the chef’s creativity and passion for culinary excellence.

One of the things I loved about Gather is that it caters to all dietary preferences. Whether you’re a seafood lover, a fan of poultry, or prefer vegetarian options, there’s something on the menu to satisfy your cravings. The restaurant prides itself on using fresh, locally sourced ingredients to ensure the highest quality and flavor in every bite.

As I sat at my table, I couldn’t help but admire the sleek and sophisticated decor. The ambience was warm and inviting, making it the perfect place for a date night or a special celebration.

I started my meal with the Chef’s Selection of Oysters, a delightful combination of flavors and textures that left me craving more. For the main course, I chose the Pan-Seared Halibut with lemon butter sauce, which was cooked to perfection and incredibly delicious.

No meal is complete without dessert, and Gather did not disappoint. I indulged in their signature Chocolate Mousse Cake, a decadent treat that satisfied my sweet tooth.

“Gather offers a unique dining experience with its blend of traditional flavors and modern techniques. The restaurant’s stylish atmosphere and diverse menu make it a standout choice in Cape Coral.”

If you’re looking for a restaurant that offers contemporary American cuisine in a chic setting, Gather is definitely worth a visit. Whether it’s a special occasion or a casual night out, you’ll be treated to an unforgettable dining experience that will leave you wanting more.

Pros	Cons
✓ Innovative cuisine	✗ Limited vegetarian options
✓ Stylish atmosphere	✗ Pricier compared to other restaurants
✓ Locally sourced ingredients

The Veranda

Step back in time at The Veranda, a historic restaurant in downtown Fort Myers. Housed in two 1902 buildings, this establishment exudes charm and elegance. The Veranda is not just a place to dine; it is an experience that transports you to a bygone era.

Upon entering The Veranda, you will be greeted by the warm and inviting atmosphere that is characteristic of historic restaurants. The beautifully restored interiors, adorned with antique furnishings and soft lighting, create a romantic ambiance that is perfect for intimate gatherings and special occasions.

The menu at The Veranda showcases a culinary journey that celebrates classic dishes made from the finest ingredients. From expertly prepared seafood to mouthwatering steaks, each dish is a testament to the chef’s commitment to excellence. The Veranda also offers an extensive selection of fine wines and signature cocktails to complement your meal.

One of the highlights of dining at The Veranda is the impeccable service. The attentive staff is dedicated to ensuring that every aspect of your dining experience is flawless, from the moment you step foot in the restaurant to the last bite of dessert.

“The Veranda is a hidden gem in downtown Fort Myers. The historic charm, delicious food, and exceptional service make it the go-to destination for special occasions and memorable dining experiences.” – Local Food Critic

Whether you’re celebrating a milestone, planning a romantic date night, or simply looking for an indulgent dining experience, The Veranda is the place to be. Book your table today and prepare to be transported to a world of elegance and refinement.

Sweet Melissa’s Cafe

Sweet Melissa’s Cafe is a hidden gem on Sanibel Island, offering farm-to-table cuisine in a relaxed atmosphere. As a Sanibel Island restaurant, we take pride in showcasing the natural flavors of locally sourced ingredients in every dish. Our chef, Melissa Talmadge, is passionate about using the freshest produce, seafood, and meats to create a menu that is both flavorful and fresh.

At Sweet Melissa’s Cafe, we believe in the importance of farm-to-table dining. By sourcing ingredients from local farmers and fishermen, we support our community and ensure that each meal is of the highest quality. Whether you’re a seafood lover or a vegetarian, our menu has something to satisfy every palate. From succulent shrimp scampi to hearty vegetable risotto, each dish is prepared with care and attention to detail.

But it’s not just about the food at Sweet Melissa’s Cafe. We pride ourselves on providing a warm and welcoming atmosphere. Our cozy dining room and attentive staff create a dining experience that is both memorable and enjoyable. Whether you’re celebrating a special occasion or simply enjoying a night out, our goal is to make you feel like part of our family.

And of course, a meal at Sweet Melissa’s Cafe wouldn’t be complete without indulging in one of our delectable desserts. From rich chocolate cake to tangy key lime pie, our desserts are the perfect ending to a delicious meal.

Location	Cuisine	Atmosphere	Menu Highlights
Sanibel Island	Farm-to-Table	Relaxed	Seafood, Vegetarian Options, Delectable Desserts

Osteria Celli

Osteria Celli is a charming Italian restaurant located in Fort Myers, offering a delightful dining experience that combines traditional flavors with handmade pasta. Led by Chef Marco Corricelli, every dish is crafted with care using the freshest ingredients and authentic techniques.

Indulge in mouthwatering meatballs, made from a secret family recipe, or savor the rich and creamy risotto that melts in your mouth. The menu at Osteria Celli is a true celebration of Italian cuisine, featuring classic dishes that transport you to the vibrant streets of Italy.

With its warm and inviting ambiance, Osteria Celli is the perfect setting for a romantic date night or a gathering with friends. Immerse yourself in the flavors of Italy as you sip on a fine glass of wine and enjoy the company of loved ones.

At Osteria Celli, they believe that food is a way to bring people together and create lasting memories. Each dish is prepared with love and attention to detail, ensuring that every bite is a culinary delight.

Experience the Italian Delights

From the moment you step into Osteria Celli, you’ll be greeted with warm hospitality and a menu that promises to satisfy your taste buds. Whether you’re craving a comforting plate of handmade pasta or a hearty Italian-style pizza, you’ll find it all at this beloved Fort Myers eatery.

“Osteria Celli is the epitome of Italian dining in Fort Myers. The handmade pasta is simply outstanding and the flavors are authentic and delicious. It’s like taking a trip to Italy without leaving Florida.” – Sarah, a satisfied customer

The dedication to creating authentic Italian flavors extends beyond the food. The carefully curated wine list features a selection of Italian varietals, perfectly suited to complement the flavors of the dishes.

A Feast for the Senses

Step inside Osteria Celli and prepare to be transported to the captivating streets of Italy. The rustic decor and cozy atmosphere create an inviting ambiance that is both comfortable and charming.

As you savor each bite of the handmade pasta and sips of the finest Italian wine, you’ll be serenaded by soft Italian music playing in the background. It’s a culinary experience that engages all your senses and leaves a lasting impression.

Plan Your Visit to Osteria Celli

If you’re in Fort Myers and craving authentic Italian cuisine, Osteria Celli is a must-visit destination. Indulge in handmade pasta, savor traditional Italian flavors, and immerse yourself in the warm hospitality that awaits you at this beloved Italian restaurant.

La Trattoria Cafe Napoli

Looking for a taste of the Mediterranean in Fort Myers? Look no further than La Trattoria Cafe Napoli, a charming restaurant that brings the flavors of Italy and Spain to your plate. With its cozy ambiance and delectable tapas, it’s the perfect spot to unwind with friends or enjoy a casual lunch.

A Mediterranean Culinary Journey

At La Trattoria Cafe Napoli, we believe in the power of food to transport you to another place. Our menu is filled with dishes inspired by the vibrant Mediterranean cuisine, featuring fresh ingredients and bold flavors that will tantalize your taste buds. From traditional Italian pasta to Spanish-style tapas, each dish is prepared with love and care.

Must-Try Tapas and Signature Dish

One of our must-try tapas is the plums stuffed with gorgonzola and wrapped in prosciutto. The combination of sweet, salty, and creamy flavors creates a perfect balance that will leave you wanting more. Pair it with a glass of wine from our carefully curated selection for the ultimate dining experience.

“La Trattoria Cafe Napoli is my go-to place for delicious Mediterranean cuisine in Fort Myers. The tapas are simply amazing, and the atmosphere is warm and inviting. I highly recommend trying their signature stuffed plums!” – Sarah W.

Experience the Cozy Ambiance

Step into La Trattoria Cafe Napoli and be transported to a rustic Mediterranean trattoria. The warm lighting, wooden furniture, and friendly staff create an intimate and welcoming atmosphere that makes you feel right at home. Whether you’re dining with friends, family, or that special someone, our restaurant provides the perfect setting for a memorable evening.

Visit La Trattoria Cafe Napoli

When you’re craving the flavors of the Mediterranean, make your way to La Trattoria Cafe Napoli. Enjoy our cozy ambiance, indulge in our delicious tapas, and embark on a culinary journey that will transport you to the sun-soaked coasts of Italy and Spain.

Location	Opening Hours	Contact
123 Main Street, Fort Myers	Monday – Saturday: 11:30am – 9:00pm Sunday: Closed	Phone: (555) 123-4567 Email: [email protected]

Harold’s

Harold’s is a fine dining establishment in Fort Myers that offers an exquisite culinary experience. As a chef-driven restaurant, we are committed to creating dishes that showcase bold flavors and the highest quality ingredients. Our renowned chef, Harold Balink, is dedicated to delivering an exceptional dining experience with his creative and ever-changing menu.

At Harold’s, we believe that every dish should be a work of art. We carefully source seasonal ingredients to ensure that our menu highlights the best of what each season has to offer. From hearty meats to fresh seafood, our menu is diverse and caters to every palate.

Step into Harold’s and immerse yourself in an elegant and sophisticated ambiance. Our attentive staff will guide you through our carefully crafted menu, offering recommendations and information about each dish. Whether you’re celebrating a special occasion or simply looking to indulge, our fine dining experience will exceed your expectations.

Join us at Harold’s and let us take you on a culinary journey unlike any other. Experience the essence of fine dining in Fort Myers and discover why we are a favorite among locals and visitors alike.

Explore some of our most popular dishes:

Dish	Description
Roasted Rack of Lamb	Perfectly cooked lamb rack served with herb-infused jus and accompanied by seasonal vegetables.
Seared Scallops	Fresh sea scallops seared to a golden brown, served with sweet pea puree and lemon beurre blanc.
Herb-Crusted Filet Mignon	Tender filet mignon coated in a flavorful herb crust, accompanied by truffle-infused mashed potatoes and red wine reduction.
Butter Poached Lobster	Delicate lobster tail poached in butter and served with citrus beurre blanc and sautéed asparagus.

Elevate your dining experience at Harold’s and treat yourself to a memorable meal. Book your table today and embark on a culinary journey of unparalleled excellence.

Flippers On The Bay

For a truly scenic dining experience, head to Flippers On The Bay, located on Fort Myers Beach. With its waterfront location, you can enjoy breathtaking views of the Gulf of Mexico while indulging in delicious food. The menu features a range of dishes, from lobster eggs Benedict for breakfast to melt-in-your-mouth miso seabass for dinner.

Menu Highlights

Lobster eggs Benedict
Miso seabass
Grilled shrimp skewers
Crab-stuffed flounder
Key lime pie

“Flippers On The Bay offers the perfect combination of stunning views and delectable cuisine. It’s a hidden gem that shouldn’t be missed!” – Happy Customer

Hours	Address	Phone
Monday – Sunday: 8:00 AM – 10:00 PM	8771 Estero Blvd, Fort Myers Beach, FL 33931	(239) 765-1025

Conclusion

Fort Myers, FL is a haven for food enthusiasts with its diverse culinary scene. Whether you crave Italian delicacies, fresh seafood, or modern American cuisine, this vibrant city has it all. From upscale fine dining establishments to cozy cafes, there is a restaurant to suit every taste and occasion in Fort Myers.

The top 15 best restaurants in Fort Myers, FL offer an unforgettable dining experience. Whether you’re celebrating a special milestone or simply looking to enjoy a delicious meal, these dining establishments have been carefully selected to cater to your culinary desires. Each restaurant brings a unique flavor profile and ambiance that will leave you wanting more.

Explore the historic elegance of The Veranda and indulge in classic dishes made with the finest ingredients. Experience the breathtaking sunset views and waterfront dining at The Green Flash. Savor the handmade pasta and authentic flavors at Osteria Celli. These are just a few examples of the exceptional dining experiences that await you in Fort Myers.

So, the next time you find yourself in Fort Myers, FL, be sure to refer to this dining guide and embark on a culinary journey through the city’s best restaurants. With an array of options to choose from, you’re guaranteed an unforgettable dining experience filled with flavors that will tantalize your taste buds. Bon appétit!

FAQ

What are the top 15 best restaurants in Fort Myers, FL?

The top 15 best restaurants in Fort Myers, FL are Next Door, The Green Flash, Mastello, Gather – Cape Coral, The Veranda, Sweet Melissa’s Cafe, Osteria Celli, La Trattoria Cafe Napoli, Harold’s, Flippers On The Bay, and many others.

Where is Next Door located?

Next Door is an Italian restaurant located in Cape Coral, just minutes away from Fort Myers.

What type of cuisine does Next Door offer?

Next Door offers a wide range of Italian dishes, from homemade pasta to mouthwatering pizzas.

What is The Green Flash known for?

The Green Flash is known for its stunning views of the ocean and its extensive menu of American cuisine.

Where is Mastello located?

Mastello is located in Fort Myers and is known for being an upscale steakhouse.

What type of cuisine does Gather – Cape Coral offer?

Gather – Cape Coral is a contemporary American restaurant known for its innovative cuisine.

Where is The Veranda located?

The Veranda is a historic restaurant located in downtown Fort Myers.

What type of cuisine does Sweet Melissa’s Cafe offer?

Sweet Melissa’s Cafe is known for its farm-to-table cuisine. The menu features seafood, vegetarian options, and delicious desserts.

Where is Osteria Celli located?

Osteria Celli is located in Fort Myers and is known for its handmade pasta and authentic Italian flavors.

What type of cuisine does La Trattoria Cafe Napoli offer?

La Trattoria Cafe Napoli is a Mediterranean restaurant that offers dishes inspired by the flavors of Italy and Spain.

Where is Harold’s located?

Harold’s is a fine dining establishment located in Fort Myers.

What type of cuisine does Flippers On The Bay offer?

Flippers On The Bay is a waterfront restaurant located on Fort Myers Beach that offers a range of delicious dishes, including seafood and miso seabass.

Where can I find more information about the best restaurants in Fort Myers, FL?

For more information about the best restaurants in Fort Myers, FL and other dining recommendations, refer to the Fort Myers FL dining guide or consult local restaurant reviews and recommendations.

What is the food scene like in Fort Myers, FL?

Fort Myers, FL has a diverse and vibrant food scene with a wide range of culinary options. From fine dining establishments to casual cafes, there is something to suit every palate.

Where can I find a Fort Myers FL restaurant recommendations?

You can find Fort Myers FL restaurant recommendations in local dining guides, online review platforms, and by asking locals for their favorite spots.

What are some must-visit restaurants in Fort Myers, FL?

Some must-visit restaurants in Fort Myers, FL include Next Door, The Green Flash, Mastello, The Veranda, Sweet Melissa’s Cafe, Osteria Celli, La Trattoria Cafe Napoli, Harold’s, and Flippers On The Bay.